Nepedia
Back to Discover
Advanced Reader
🎨

Art criticism

arts Maturity 7-9 Next article →

Art criticism is the formal discussion and evaluation of visual art. It involves interpreting the value of a work through various lenses. Critics often work within the context of aesthetics, which is the study of beauty. They also use art theory to find a rational basis for appreciation. This activity can be highly subjective based on personal preference. However, it can also be based on the principles of design. It may also rely on social and cultural acceptance.

Gabriel Cornelius von Max, 1840-1915, Monkeys as Judges of Art, 1889
Gabriel Cornelius von Max, 1840-1915, Monkeys as Judges of Art, 1889

The methodology of criticism usually follows a specific sequence. A critic begins with a descriptive aspect of the work. They translate the visual elements into words for an audience. This allows a logical case to be made about the piece. After description, the critic moves into the evaluation phase. This evaluation depends on the artist's output and the critic's experience. Some critics prefer to remark on immediate, sensory impressions. Others use a systematic approach involving technical knowledge. They might also study the sociocultural context of the artist. This helps them discern the original intent of the creator.

There are several distinct types of art criticism in practice. The field is often divided into historical and contemporary disciplines. Historical criticism is a form of art history that evaluates past works. Contemporary criticism focuses on the work of living artists. Critics may also use different theories to guide their judgments. These include formalist, expressive, and mimetic theories. Some use postmodern or relativist theories to view art. Others look through the lens of ritual or cognition. These different frameworks change how a critic perceives value.

History shows that critiques likely began with art itself. Early ideas appear in the texts of Plato and Vitruvius. During the Renaissance, wealthy patrons used evaluators to help them buy art. The term "art criticism" was coined by Jonathan Richardson in 1719. He published a book called An Essay on the Whole Art of Criticism. Richardson attempted to create an objective ranking system. He used seven categories, such as drawing and composition. Each category received a score from 0 to 18. These scores were combined to produce a final total.

Jonathan Richardson by Jonathan Richardson
Jonathan Richardson by Jonathan Richardson

In the 18th century, art criticism became a popular genre of writing. Public interest grew with the Salons in Paris and London exhibitions. Jean-Baptiste Dubos gained acclaim for his approach to aesthetic theory. Étienne La Font de Saint-Yenne wrote about the socioeconomic framework of Baroque art. Denis Diderot greatly advanced the medium in France. His writing on the Salon of 1765 captured art through words. In England, the Morning Chronicle became the first newspaper to systematically review exhibitions in the 1770s. This period saw the rise of the professional critic.

The 19th century saw criticism become a formal vocation. In France, a rift emerged between Neoclassicists and Romantics. Neoclassicists like Étienne-Jean Delécluze preferred finished, classical forms. Romantics like Stendhal championed emotional and expressive nuances. In England, John Ruskin became a preeminent figure. He published Modern Painters in 1843. His work was a massive, scientific analysis of art.

John Ruskin - Project Gutenberg eText 13103
John Ruskin - Project Gutenberg eText 13103

Another major figure was the poet Charles Baudelaire. He wrote bold reviews, such as his Salon of 1845.

Étienne Carjat, Portrait of Charles Baudelaire, circa 1862
Étienne Carjat, Portrait of Charles Baudelaire, circa 1862

Criticism can sometimes lead to intense conflict between artists and critics. John Ruskin once derided James McNeill Whistler's work. He accused Whistler of flinging a pot of paint in the public's face. This harsh critique led to a famous libel lawsuit. Whistler won the case, but it was a Pyrrhic victory. At the turn of the 20th century, the focus shifted again. Roger Fry and Clive Bell championed modernist abstraction. Fry's 1910 exhibition of post-Impressionist art was very controversial.

Roger Fry self-portrait
Roger Fry self-portrait

His work helped change the direction of public taste.

Clive Bell
Clive Bell

Art criticism remains connected to many broader academic fields. It overlaps significantly with art history and sociology. The borders between these disciplines are no longer firmly drawn. This is because art historians now take a deep interest in modern art. Criticism also relates to psychology through the study of perception. It touches on politics through the study of socioeconomic frameworks. Because art is a human instinct, criticism helps us navigate its diverse forms. It allows us to move from simple observation to deep understanding.

696 words

Where will your curiosity go next?

Keep exploring at your chosen reading level.

🖼️ Images & Media (6)
File:Gabriel Cornelius von Max, 1840-1915, Monkeys as Judges of Art, 1889.jpg
Gabriel Cornelius von Max, 1840-1915,...
File:Jonathan Richardson by Jonathan Richardson.jpg
Jonathan Richardson by Jonathan Richardson.jpg
File:John Ruskin - Project Gutenberg eText 13103.jpg
John Ruskin - Project Gutenberg eText 13103.jpg
File:Étienne Carjat, Portrait of Charles Baudelaire, circa 1862.jpg
Étienne Carjat, Portrait of Charles...
File:Roger Fry self-portrait.jpg
Roger Fry self-portrait.jpg
File:Clive Bell.jpg
Clive Bell.jpg
More to explore

🔬 Go deeper

More advanced topics to explore

🪜 Step back

Simpler topics to build understanding

What is Nepedia?

A free, ad-free encyclopedia for children. Every article is written at five reading levels, so the same page works for a five-year-old and a fifteen-year-old — use the level switcher above to see this one change. No account needed to read.