The working ingredients and method form one recipe. Different formulas are compared without averaging their quantities or rise schedules.
Recipe
Black-and-white iced cookies
Soft cake-like cookies with two-tone icing.
How do I make it?
1
Mix dry
1 min
Whisk dry group.
Whisk the flour, leaveners and salt until evenly combined.
Ready when: Even.
2
Cream
3 min
Beat butter and sugar until light.
Beat the softened butter and caster sugar until pale and fluffy.
Ready when: Fluffy.
3
Combine
2 min
Beat in wet ingredients, then mix in dry group briefly.
Mix in the egg and sour cream, then combine briefly with the dry ingredients to make a thick batter.
Ready when: Thick batter.
4
Bake
16–18 min
Heat oven to 175°C. Scoop 50 g mounds well apart on lined trays; bake.
Scoop 50 g mounds well apart on the lined tray before baking.
Ready when: Centres spring back.
5
Cool
Until cold
Cool completely on a rack.
Cool the baked cookies completely on a rack before icing.
Ready when: Ready to ice.
6
Ice
About 1 hour
Mix icing group. Coat half the flat underside of each cookie. Stir cocoa and extra milk into remaining icing; coat other halves. Let set.
Ice each flat underside half white and half chocolate, then leave the icing to set.
Ready when: Icing no longer tacky.
What can go wrong, and how can I fix it?
What you notice
Likely cause
What to do
Excessive spreading
Warm dough or tray.
Chill the remaining dough and use a cool tray. Use the stated ingredient weights.
Dry or hard cookies
Overbaking.
Store airtight once cool. Check the first tray early.
Useful recipe notes
Icing is a thin coating; add milk a few drops at a time if needed. Keep airtight for 2 days.
See the detailed method and ratios in , or follow ingredients through the .
Ingredient proportions & recipe details
Black-and-white iced cookies at a glance
Makes
About 15 cookies
Heat
175°C conventional
Baking time
16–18 min
How do the ingredient proportions compare?
Percentages compare each listed weight with the combined flour weight (100%). These are ingredient ratios, not dough hydration; milk, eggs and fillings contain other ingredients as well as water.